Date:Fri, 21 Mar 1997 17:58:46 -0800
Reply-To:Biological Conservation and GIS <[log in to unmask]>
Sender:Biological Conservation and GIS <[log in to unmask]>
From:Patrick Moore <[log in to unmask]>
Subject:Re: Re: spotted owl victory
on Thursday, March 20, 1997 3:09 PM Kai Snyder wrote
> REPLY: You missed my point here: fire fighters rarely put out big fires.
> doesn't matter how many helicopters, tankers, etc. they have. I'm not
> fire fighters, though. If a forest fire was threatening my home, I'd want
> people to help me save it. But its a fallacy to think that they are
> out fires. I encourage you to look into it. Fire fighters don't do much
> way or the other for spotted owl habitat. Patrick's example could have
> better chosen.
Whoa again! Has it occurred to you the the big fires are only the ones they
couldn't put out? That doesn't mean they didn't put out lots of fires that
might have become big if they hadn't put them out. My example was well
chosen and spotted owls and millions of other critters die in fires but not
so much in logging unless it is really unsustainable.
When you say "Fire fighters rarely put out big fires" perhaps you should
remenber Yellowstone, 1988. After one million acres had burned, fire
fighters put the fire out (at a cost of $125 million).
I will reply to your earlier response later as I am in the middle of a
conference at Berkeley campus on the definition of sustainable forestry.
Many angels are on the head of this pin!
Patrick Moore, GREENSPIRIT
4068 West 32nd Avenue
Vancouver BC, CANADA V6S 1Z6
(604) 221-1990 phone/fax
e-mail [log in to unmask]
May the Forest be With You